The temple of Saint Cuthbert is a stout stone structure near the waterfront, not far from Lost Lovers Beach. The building stands in stark contrast to the weathered wooden buildings that surround it. The tall, narrow windows on its exterior resemble archer slits. The windows are made of thick blurry glass and allow only an extremely distorted view of the inside.

Within is a square, rather plain worship area with long, hardwood plank benches serving as pews. At the front is a matching table upon which rests some lit candles and prayer books. A starburst pattern of red glass is visible on the wall above the table.